I submitted an account, and it came back declined. What do I tell my client, and what do I do next?
A declined submission feels worse than it is, especially if you built it up with your client before you had the answer. But how you handle the next conversation matters more than the decline itself.
The first thing is to understand why it came back declined before you say anything to your client. Was it the loss history, the premium level, the type of business or something in the operations? We'll tell you. We don't decline accounts and leave agents guessing. You need to know what the issue was so you can have a real conversation rather than just deliver bad news without context.
Once you understand the reason, go back to your client directly. Don't avoid the conversation and don't minimize it. Something like this: I got the results back on the captive review, and it didn't come back as approved. Here's what they found, and here's what it means.
Then explain it in plain terms. If it was losses, say that. The loss history over the last five years made it hard for the underwriting team to build a case for the economics. If it were a premium level, say that. The numbers weren't quite at the threshold where the captive structure makes financial sense for your size. If it was operations or a specific exposure, say that too.
Here's what you don't do. Don't act like the captive review process failed your client. The review process did exactly what it's supposed to do. It protected both sides from entering an arrangement that wasn't built to succeed. A declined account isn't a rejection of your client as a person or even as a business. It means the numbers and the timing weren't aligned.
Now here's the next move. Most declines aren't permanent. They're timing issues or trajectory issues. If it was losses, get us on a call with your client. We'll tell them exactly what needs to change and what the path forward looks like. We've done this many times. Sometimes that conversation turns into a six or twelve-month plan where the client works on their safety culture, gets their losses trending down, and comes back in a position to get approved. You stay in the seat the whole time as their advisor, and you look like the person who was working on their behalf, even when the first answer was no.
Don't go to the well twice without a solution. But go back.
It's always your client. Never ours.
Topics:
